MOVIE AND BOOK REVIEW
By:
Students of State Polytechnic of Malang
DIII English for Translation and Hospitality Industry
1C
Subject: Listening II
1. Fanny Fajar Aprilia - 1932810028/10
2. Indah Ramadhani - 1932810007/14
3. Tharieza Nila Amelia - 1932810064/27
4. Yunita Afza Viradilla - 1932810085/28
THE FAULT IN OUR STARS
MOVIE vs BOOK
Name : Isaac
Physical characteristics : He is a tall man with black glasses on her eyes. He is totally blind because of eyes cancer that attacked him for quite long time. His skin is white and smooth. His style is similar with Augustus, he wears shirt, jeans and black leather jacket.
Personality : He is an open minded human being. Warm, chatty and supportive.
Costumes : Dark jeans troussers, short shirt and black leather jacket.
Relationship with other characters : He is an Augustus's best friend. He is an active member of Cancer Support Group, that is why he also knows Hazel and they often spend their times together.
Illustration :
1. The casts name between novel and film (especially for main characters: Hazel Grace Lancaster and Augustus Wazer).
2. The age of Hazel and August.
3. Hazel and Augustus’s disease.
4. Hazel and Augustus tried to live ‘normally’.
5. The plot when Hazel and August met for the first time in Support Group.
6. Hazel and Augustus’s trip to Amsterdam with Hazel’s mom to meet Hazel’s favorite author, Peter van Houten.
7. The characteristic of Peter van Houten; arrogant, sensitive, drunker, and don’t show his appreciate for Hazel and Augustus (especially for Hazel) who want to visit him as their favorite author.
8. Hazel and Augustus are often texting to each others.
9. Augustus died in the end of the story.
10. There is a letter from Augustus for Hazel at Peter van Houten.
By:
Students of State Polytechnic of Malang
DIII English for Translation and Hospitality Industry
1C
Subject: Listening II
1. Fanny Fajar Aprilia - 1932810028/10
2. Indah Ramadhani - 1932810007/14
3. Tharieza Nila Amelia - 1932810064/27
4. Yunita Afza Viradilla - 1932810085/28
THE FAULT IN OUR STARS
MOVIE vs BOOK
- Characters
1.Name : Hazel Grace Lancaster
Physical characteristics : She has a light brown and smacking hair. Her nose is perfectly sharp, with a little bit freckles on it. Hazel’s eyes is so beautiful and shine as crystal with brown pupil. Her lips is pink naturally, she does not need too much make up though. Her height is around 170 cm, and the weight is around 55 kg. She also has a perfect black-hairy eyebrows.
Personality : Hazel is an intelligent, kind, and cool teenager. She is genuinely smart due to her hobby. Her hobby is reading the same novel to help her find out the real meaning of each novel. She feels blessed of every things which happen to her. Hazel is a brave and confident girl.
Costumes : Hazel loves wearing t-shirt during the daily days. Once she went to the restaurant in Dutch, she wears a blue dress which very suit on her.
Relationship with other character : Hazel is the one and only daughter of Frannie Lancaster and Michael Lancaster. Hazel joins a group of cancer (group for people who have cancer disease). She has a mentor named Patrick, friends named August (who also her crush) and Isaac. Hazel doctor’s is Dr. Maria. Hazel also knows August’s parents, Mrs and Mr Waters.
2. Name : Augustus Waters
Physical characteristics : Augustus is a charming and smart boy. He is really handsome. He has a sharp nose and small brown eyes. His hair is also brown, and a little bit black. He is a tall boy, his height is around 180cm with weight 60kg. He has a light and white skin.
Personality : Augustus is a charmy, soft and sensitive boy. He loves helping his family and people around him. He is very friendly and has a phobia of flying.
Costumes : He loves wearing t-shirt and jacket. But once he also wears a black coat when he went to the restaurant with Hazel.
Relationship with other characteristics : He was raised by his parents, mrs Watees and mr Waters. They are very close and supportive. He has a crush on Hazel and he has a bestfriend as well, named Isaac.
3. Name : Frannie Lancaster
Physical characteristic : Frannie Lancaster is Hazel’s mom. She has a yellow-brown straight hair. Her nose is perfectly sharp with her brown eyes and pinkish lips.
Personality : She is a cute mom of Hazel with her patience and love character. She is taking care of Hazel all the time. She always supports her daughter through her difficult times.
Costumes : She loves wearing t-shirt and jacket.
Relationship with other characters : Frannie is a wife of Michael Lancaster and a mother of Hazel. She also quite close with August and his family and Dr. Maria as well.
4.Name : Michael Lancaster
Physical characteristics : Michael is a Hazel’s dad. He has a brown-black hair. His eyes is beautiful combines with his perfect sharp nose and his browny skin. He is nor very tall I guess.
Personality : He is super lovable dad. He is a funny and smart dad, because he loves talking about culture to his family. He also very patient and wise.
Costumes : As a usual man, he loves wearing shirt every single time. Except on the special occasion, he will wear a suit.
Relationship with other characters : He is a Frannie’s husband and Hazel’s dad. But, he also know Augustus’s parents well, and so Dr. Maria as Hazel’s doctor.
Illustration :
Name : Isaac
Physical characteristics : He is a tall man with black glasses on her eyes. He is totally blind because of eyes cancer that attacked him for quite long time. His skin is white and smooth. His style is similar with Augustus, he wears shirt, jeans and black leather jacket.
Personality : He is an open minded human being. Warm, chatty and supportive.
Costumes : Dark jeans troussers, short shirt and black leather jacket.
Relationship with other characters : He is an Augustus's best friend. He is an active member of Cancer Support Group, that is why he also knows Hazel and they often spend their times together.
Illustration :
Name : Dr. Maria
Physical characteristics : A 37th year old-woman who being a doctor for keeping Hazel's disease. She has a brown(tan) skin, which means really exotic and beautiful. She has a straight and short hair.
Personality : She is an ambitious woman, but very kind. She does liability of everything she had decided. She does not easily give up through her hard times, indeed, she is persisted.
Costumes : As a commonly doctor, she wears a white suit (doctor suit) with stethoscope in her neck. She loves wearing short skirt or sometimes long troussers with blouse.
Relationship with other characters : She is a Hazel's doctor since the very first time Hazel was diagnozed by her disease. She has a good communication among her parents.
Illustration :
Physical characteristics : A 37th year old-woman who being a doctor for keeping Hazel's disease. She has a brown(tan) skin, which means really exotic and beautiful. She has a straight and short hair.
Personality : She is an ambitious woman, but very kind. She does liability of everything she had decided. She does not easily give up through her hard times, indeed, she is persisted.
Costumes : As a commonly doctor, she wears a white suit (doctor suit) with stethoscope in her neck. She loves wearing short skirt or sometimes long troussers with blouse.
Relationship with other characters : She is a Hazel's doctor since the very first time Hazel was diagnozed by her disease. She has a good communication among her parents.
Illustration :
Name : Peter Van Houten
Physical characteristics : He has a white skin and his eyes are green. He wears glasses every time, shawl, and cardigan.
Personality : A middle-aged man who has an arrogant personality, a drunker, and selfish. He likes to underestimate others.
Costumes : He wears a long shirt andtroussers with shawl in his neck.
Relationship with other characters : He is an author of Hazel's favourite book, An Imperial Affliction. Hazel is imppresed by him and wants to meet him face to face to ask about that book.
Illustration :
- PLOT
This modern story has a combination plot. The explanation is, from the beginning of this story (whether in novel or film) it shows a 16 years old of girl who has a lung cancer, named Hazel. In the middle of he story, the film and novel describe how Hazel used to be (when she struggled her disease, which is started at the age of 4). Then, the story continue to Hazel’s life now as teenagers. During that, the viewers will find the ups and downs overcoming a cancer disease, combine with her group of cancer, her family, her love-life with Augustus. But this story is unpredictable I guess, and I believe you too. The ending is surprising and the messages that the viewers can get is worthy.
It is very exciting story, both film or novel. The author of the novel and the director of the film do know how to combine bliss, grief, family story, and love life become one perfect arrangement.
The highest dramatic point is where Augustus confesses his feeling to Hazel, and Hazel cries. Second, when Isaac and Hazel read a speech-text which they had written in front of Augustus, right before he died. Third, when Hazel woke up in the middle of night and suddenly she cries because she remembers that Augustus, the one she loved, is not by her side at all.
• Summary
The story in this novel and movie is about a teenager, named Hazel who suffered from Thyroid cancer, that make her cannot live without an oxygen tube to breathe. She joins weekly Support Group since her mom decided that she was depressed. This Support Group is followed by people who also have illnesses to tell their story and support each other. From this group, Hazel met Augustus. A man with osteosarcoma, a type of bone cancer that makes him lose a half of his legs. Also Isaac, Augustus's friend who has eyes cancer. Since then Hazel and Augustus are getting closer. Hazel comes to Augustus's house and vice versa.
Hazel really likes reading a novel, one of her favorite novel is An Imperial Affliction by Peter Van Houten. The novel is about cancer, and Hazel is really curious about the ending. She always sends the email to the author to ask about it, but everything she got is nothing. Until one day, the author give her a chance to meet in person at Amsterdam. It's all because of Augustus who kindly helps her. But everything didn't go well, Hazel gets something that she didn't expect from the author. The author said that the novel didn't have ending. On the other side, for the very first time they go to Amsterdam, Augustus confesses her feeling to her. The last day they are in Amsterdam, Augustus tells Hazel about his illness that getting worst. One night, while Augustus is driving, his disease recurred.
Augustus realizes that he does not have much time anymore. So he asks Hazel and Isaac to make a speech for him before he gone. They read it at chruch. And after that, Augustus Waters passed away. Being forgotten is the biggest fear for Augustus, but now at least he has 2 people that will always remember him, Isaac, and his beloved girl Hazel. Hazel always says that she does not need everyone to remember her, one is enough.
- Similarites
1. The casts name between novel and film (especially for main characters: Hazel Grace Lancaster and Augustus Wazer).
2. The age of Hazel and August.
3. Hazel and Augustus’s disease.
4. Hazel and Augustus tried to live ‘normally’.
5. The plot when Hazel and August met for the first time in Support Group.
6. Hazel and Augustus’s trip to Amsterdam with Hazel’s mom to meet Hazel’s favorite author, Peter van Houten.
7. The characteristic of Peter van Houten; arrogant, sensitive, drunker, and don’t show his appreciate for Hazel and Augustus (especially for Hazel) who want to visit him as their favorite author.
8. Hazel and Augustus are often texting to each others.
9. Augustus died in the end of the story.
10. There is a letter from Augustus for Hazel at Peter van Houten.
• Differentiate
1. In the novel, Augustus invites Hazel to watch a film "V" for Vendeta while in the movie Augustus does invites Hazel but not actually watch it.
2. In the novel tells that Hazel looking for information about Augustus's ex-girlfriend, but in the movie this part does not exist.
3. In the novel Augustus and Hazel are discussing both the novels they bartered, while in the movie is only Hazel's novel that they're discussed.
4. In the novel, when they are going to the Netherlands Hazel and his mother pick up Augustus and know Augustus had a fight with his friend, while in the movie Augustus come pick Hazel and his mother with a limousin.
5. The swings at Hazel's house already sold but it is doesn't exist in the movie.
6. In the novel after Augustus passed away, Hazel went to Augustus's house to looked for a letter that Augustus wrote for her, but in the movie she didn't.
7. In the novel, Hazel has two friends named Kaitlyn and Matt, but it is not showed in the film.
- Messages
1.) As a human, we cannot avoid heart broke, in life we will feel heart broke not just once time and will be many times. As augustus says to Hazel "it would be privilege to have my heart broke by you"
2.) Love will change everything. Hazel and augustus loves each other, even thought they know that one of them will die because of health problems, they remain together and eager to live the day until finally they must break up.
3.) Life must go on, when we have a relationship, and that relationship have ended, our lives may not end too even when we have to be left by our family or some one whom we love. We have to survive and it's not easy.
4.) As a people who suffer a heavy disease such a cancer, we need to be patient and survive eventhough it is very hard and difficult. Keep doing a positive thing and do not forget to always pray to God.
5.) As a parents who have to be responsible for their daughter/son who is surviving in cancer, we have to be optimistic and support them every single time. All they need is us, parents and family.
- Thoughts
1. To be honest, it is hard for me to choose between novel and film. Firstly, I expected that the film is not as good as the novel. The way the writer conveys each story is beyond remarkable. BUT….. more than that, I do love the film. The casts, cinematography, the setting area, the acting, and the emotion are real. I can not move on from this story. I learned a lot from each characters who play very well. Trust me this is worth it to read and watch. Other than that, I love the combination of their accent in the film. It is an American and British accent. So there are people who talk in American accent and others talk in British accent. It is truly perfect and suit for teenagers and above. I do not really recommend this film for kids age under 13 years old because there is a adult scene. Once more, I love the cover of this book, very millenial and colorful. (Fanny)
2. This story is kind of cute and sad story that everyone wants to see or read it. The casts successfully bring me to another feeling and atmosphere while watching or reading it. How Hazel and Augustus interaction at the first tine they met until they fell in love to each others. However, this story is so good that make us cry until the end of the story. (Indah)
3. I like this story because this kind of teenagers love story, that can relate for me, eventhough I have never have those kind of rough experience. This movie also has motivating values inside. It make me more grateful God. Also, because I like a drama genre, so this movie is really in my tune. This movie, not only tells about love, but also about family, friend, struggle, and pain. That make this story is really complete. The language used in this story is informal and make me easier to understand. (Tharieza)
4. I understand the story through the film better, because when I read the book there were some parts that I could not imagine how was the situation but i think the story based on the book is more touching than the story based on the film. And i like this novel and film becaise the story about the struggle of one's life with all kinds of illnesses that he suffered but still the spirit to live and not give up, until some day they found someone who loved him very much but had to part because he died because of an illness. (Vira)
Thank you, nice viewers.
Hope this review helps a lot for you.
Feel free to comment bellow your thoughts and suggestions👇
✨✨✨✨
2. This story is kind of cute and sad story that everyone wants to see or read it. The casts successfully bring me to another feeling and atmosphere while watching or reading it. How Hazel and Augustus interaction at the first tine they met until they fell in love to each others. However, this story is so good that make us cry until the end of the story. (Indah)
3. I like this story because this kind of teenagers love story, that can relate for me, eventhough I have never have those kind of rough experience. This movie also has motivating values inside. It make me more grateful God. Also, because I like a drama genre, so this movie is really in my tune. This movie, not only tells about love, but also about family, friend, struggle, and pain. That make this story is really complete. The language used in this story is informal and make me easier to understand. (Tharieza)
4. I understand the story through the film better, because when I read the book there were some parts that I could not imagine how was the situation but i think the story based on the book is more touching than the story based on the film. And i like this novel and film becaise the story about the struggle of one's life with all kinds of illnesses that he suffered but still the spirit to live and not give up, until some day they found someone who loved him very much but had to part because he died because of an illness. (Vira)
Thank you, nice viewers.
Hope this review helps a lot for you.
Feel free to comment bellow your thoughts and suggestions👇
✨✨✨✨









Comments
Post a Comment